If You Have to Ask…
brinkley | August 7, 2011The statement “If you have to ask, you wouldn’t understand.” has been attributed to Harley Davidson for years, but it certainly applies to the hickory golfing world as well. It’s hard to explain to someone why we play with hickory clubs, but I ran across the following text in Bobby Clampet’s book The Impact Zone – Mastering Golf’s Moment of Truth that somewhat provides a reasonable explanation.
If you are ultimately concerned with improving your swing and not masking flaws, once you consistently achieve a swing bottom of two inches forward of the ball with our game-improvement irons, I suggest moving toward a blade-type design. Again, such clubs will both encourage and reward an aggressive move through the impact zone, and your swing bottom will begin to move toward that coveted four inches in front of the ball makr. This is why noted golf teacher Chuck Hogan has called bade irons true “game-improvement clubs.” When this starts to happen you’ll start to see your driver and fairway wood swings improve as well.
I have to whole heartedly agree with Bobby assessment having seen the effects in my own swing since switching to hickory clubs. I’m striking the ball much better today than I was 5 years ago. Today there were two fine examples. On hole 6, a par 5 lined with trouble on the right, I hit a 55 degree pre-1905 smooth faced Tom Stewart absolutely perfect from 75 yards out. The gutta percha replica landed 7 feet in front of pin, jumped 2 feet past, then skidded to a stop 5 feet from the hole. Imagine what a strike like that would have produced with groves (on my 1928 55 degree) and/or a modern ball.
On the 8th I pulled out my driver and hit a wonderful boring shot with just the right trajectory. As the ball is at the apex of flight my Sunday hickory playing partner says, “That’s the best shot you’ve hit all day.” As he said that I held my finish position for a moment. Everything felt right: perfect balance, rotated nicely on the left foot with straight left leg. In reviewing the swing in my mind the dynamics of the swing were all right. Good straight left hand at impact, strong loading and lag, a straight plane line through the impact zone, and a swing bottom about 4 inches in front of the ball.
As we were walking off the 9th green my hickory playing partner commented on how much better he’s been striking the ball this year with his modern clubs. He said that playing with the hickories makes you strike the ball better, thinking about all of your swing dynamics. I nodded. I just wish I could do it on every swing like I did on 6 and 8.
So if after reading this you still don’t understand don’t ask. Just get some quality “game-improvement” hickory clubs and go play and then you’ll understand.
Today the course is a muni but it didn’t start this way. When I was reading the history of the course and the associated club it reminded me in many ways of the Jekyll Island Club in Georgia. The Altadena Country Club was started, like the Jekyll Island Club, by millionaires that were looking for an escape from the harsh winters. In fact you can find history of the “Crane” family (from plumbing fame) in both locations. Back in 1912 the course and the club included some 115 acres of land along with a great club house. It was quite the social gathering place. The course was laid out by Scotsman William “Willie’ Watson. Willie has 13 golf courses to his credit the most famous being Harding Park in San Francisco but he designed courses in Michigan, Illinois, California, and Colorado including the Colorado Spring Country Club some 30 minutes from my home.
Still Altadena is fun course to play. Look at other Watson venues and you see that the course could be. The practice facility is quite nice. Unlike Brookside which is just down the street you hit on natural grass. The fairways are shaggy but the elevated greens are nicely cared for. My partner, a local in the area, told me that the course isn’t very crowded and enjoyable to play. I played my 1905 set with a gutta perch replica and found the course a bit too long from the tips at 2,948 yards. If I played it again I would probably try the Golds or possibly even the Reds. That said there are really only two holes that are two long. Hole #1 is 453 yard long par 4 and parallels hole #9 at 437 yards long. The rest of the par 4 holes are 331 yards or shorter. The lone par 5 is 446 yards (go figure that one out). The par 3s are reachable at 167 and 172 yards but took my longest iron. Hole #2 is pretty nasty though with the big tree munching balls to the left of the green and the sand trap chomping balls on the right. And don’t expect you’ll have it easy once you get on the greens. Most of the short holes are defended with devilish breaking greens that if you’re on the high side are lightning fast. You want make sure you’re on the low side of the hole.








